Friday, January 26, 2007

Fundamental and Liberal Christians.

Robin Burkhalter, Kristin Meadows, Brian Dill

Fundamental Christianity and the more liberal or mainstream Christianity divide when it comes to the belief in how and when the the world was created.

A Fundamentalist would likely point to the Bible for his answer, referring to Genesis and its account of all humankind having a common ancestry in the the personages of Adam and Eve. Since the entire human race began with them, it is understandable that the many different culture's various accounts of history are similar. Also, because the story was passed down orally from generation to generation, it is safe to assume that, over time, some aspects of the story of Creation were either distorted and recreated, or lost altogether.

On the other hand, a more liberal Christian would more than likely side with the scientific account of the origins of the world and mankind. Some liberalists believe that everything began with God, though not necessarily in the order or according to the timeline given in the Book of Genesis. There is open criticism in this camp of the fundamentalist's literal interpretation of the Creation story - the majority believing the account in Genesis as only a philosophical allegory written by Moses to give some sort of explanation as to how God created everything. A smaller minority believe this to be a myth fabricated by the Levitical priest in order to control the Jewish people. Still others believe that the story was written more in order to establish belief in polytheism (one God creating the world), and combat the contrary belief in creation by multiple gods.

Whatever their opinions as to the origins of the story, liberalists all seem to agree that the earth and all that's in it was not created in a seven day period, but rather through the evolutionary process. Their explanation as to the similarities in the many different culture's creation accounts would be more in line with scientific reasoning. This scientific approach of explaining the common "variations of the same theme" is based on a theory put forth by Carl Jung called "Collective Unconscious". In short, it is a hypothesis that there is a part of our brain that seems to retain certain information that is commonly shared by all humans. This information is somehow passed along from generation to generation, accounting for many different cultures similarities - ranging from the formation of social orders to the need for religion.

We believe, personally, that if God is the author of science, that the two must one day agree. We also think that as we receive more information about the world around us that we will eventually have to believe in either one or the other in accordance with the evidence.

Whether scientific belief or religious belief can be reconciled is another thing altogether. Most evolutionists do not want to believe in a God, whereas a religious person would rather believe there is one. One may seem to have more evidence than the other, but people usually see what they want to see.

At odds though they may be, we do believe that they both can and have contributed to the good of society.

13 comments:

cheryl j said...

I am a fundamentalist and agree totally in the biblical verson of Creation. I also think that it is possible for stories of Creation to be distorted and recreated by other cultures. Evolution scientists do not believe in God so as I do beleive I think they will always be at odds with each other.

briandill said...

I agree that the stories of Creation could have been easily distorted and recreated by other cultures.

Erica said...

I thought this article was very interesting! I personally am a fundamentalist christian. But i enjoyed reading about liberal christians and how they side with the more scientific theories. I do not believe at all with the group of people who think is was fabricated by the Levitical priest to control the Jewish people. I think that is crazy! And i would not call those people believers.

I do agree with you that God will one day explain to us everything. And science and religion will come together and make sense.

Rena' said...

I agree that Chrisitianity is a great religion and people believe what they want to believe.I also think it's according to how they were raise but overall your group creation stories was great. Good job!

briandill said...

Rena'... You are right. Christianity is a great religion and people will ultimately believe what they want to believe. Saying that it is how people are raised that determines how and what they believe is on the money. How many times do you see an athiest in a Christian home? Not very often I would imagine. Great ideas, Thanks.

ashley j said...

I totally agree with the story. I am a strong believer of the bible, and I do believe that god was our creator. Your story was great, and you also gave good details.

Robin Burkhalter said...

In response to erica's comment:

It is hard to understand how people can accept parts of the Bible and reject other parts - kind of like the Muslim's believing Jesus was a prophet, but they don't believe his follower's accurately recorded his teachings.

Maybe liberal "Christians" just think that the evidence for evolution is so great that they can't disagree with it. Since they can't let go of their belief in God so readily, they concede that maybe evolution is the way the world was created.

Who knows, maybe they just don't want to be seen as ignorant and close-minded.

Robin Burkhalter said...

In response to cheryl:

Every single person on this earth believes in something. Evolution is just as much a belief as any religion. When people believe something and form an opinion on it it is difficult to change boats in mid-stream.

Robin Burkhalter said...

Obviously no one caught that polytheism is described as "belief in one God". Its actually supposed to be "Monotheism". Polytheism is belief in multiple Gods.

Sarah Sumrall said...

Being a Fundamentalist Christian, I found this topic very interesting. I think that if you are a Christian at all, then you should believe in what the Bible says. The Bible says the world was created in seven days; therefore, I believe that is the truth. In my opinion, I don't see how it is possible for one to call himself a Christian and not believe in what the Bible says.

Lindsey said...

I, too, am a fundamentalist christian but I like reading about the liberal christians. I think it is crazy how people can believe in the Bible but believe in the scientific facts as well. Wouldn't their facts and beliefs get mixed up? I do believe that people have their right to their own beliefs though.

Krista Walley said...

Personally I don't believe in liberal christians. I think if you are a christian, you are a true christian and live (to your best ability) exactly by the Bible. I believe that God created us just like the Bible says. You guys did a good job on this post.

Kyle said...

I agree with the biblical version of Creation as well. God made things in a set pattern for His reasons and not for us to know why. And for this reason, people may try to "think" of different ways or versions of Creation because they don't understand His pattern. God wants a full Christian, not a luke-warm one.